A Fan’s Retrospective on the 10th Anniversary of Captain America: Winter Soldier
In 2011, I saw my first MCU film with my dad, Captain America: The First Avenger. Afterward, as we left the theater and discussed what we liked, I told my dad, “He’s not dead, you know. Bucky, I mean.” Having read the comic books and databases for years beforehand, I knew that Bucky Barnes wasn’t dead despite his apparent demise in The First Avenger. He would eventually return as the Winter Soldier, a brainwashed assassin who would serve as one of Steve Rogers’ most significant, most personal challenges to date. Thus, as the MCU entered into its second phase, the film I looked forward to seeing the most, even more than the next Avengers film, was Captain America: The Winter Soldier.
This month, we mark a significant milestone in the ever-evolving MCU- the 10th anniversary of Captain America: The Winter Soldier. In this decade, we’ve witnessed the departure of Black Widow, Steve Rogers’ retirement, and the rise of the Falcon as the new Captain America. Amidst these transformative events, it’s essential to reflect on the enduring legacy of The Winter Soldier. While it may not have reached the same blockbuster status as the Avengers films or some later MCU installments, Captain America: The Winter Soldier remains a pivotal cornerstone of the franchise for two compelling reasons.
The Return of Bucky Would Have Far-Reaching Consequences
As previously stated, I knew Bucky Barnes would return from the moment of his apparent death in The First Avenger. What I hadn’t expected, though, was for the MCU to completely change who found him and turn him into a brainwashed assassin. Since it was the Soviet Union that found him in the comics, the idea of HYDRA never crossed my mind—in hindsight, though, having Cap’s best friend saved by the people who are his worst enemies feels far more appropriate. Not only does it hurt Steve personally, but his desire to save him becomes a driving force behind many of Captain America’s actions in the future.
It’s not explicitly said in The Winter Soldier or Civil War, but it should be apparent that Steve’s desire to protect Bucky goes beyond being his best friend. To Steve, Bucky represents a link to his life before he was frozen, the only link left once Peggy dies. Try as he might, he can’t give that up, and while he was right to defend him, it would still have terrible consequences. Zemo’s framing of Bucky led to the civil war that tore the Avengers apart. That, in turn, left Earth underprepared for the arrival of Thanos in Infinity War, which led to the death of half of all life in the universe. Good going, HYDRA!
The Fall of S.H.I.E.L.D. Was a Turning Point in the MCU
Thanks to the comic books telling me beforehand, the return of Bucky as the Winter Soldier didn’t surprise me. What did surprise me, though, was how the events of the film would end up leading to the near-collapse of S.H.I.E.L.D.
From its inception, S.H.I.E.L.D. had this role as the “Big Good” in the MCU. Even if Fury is known for making morally questionable decisions at times, by and large, S.H.I.E.L.D. had kept the world safe for decades. They were the whole reason that the Avengers existed in the first place, and Nick Fury was their badass leader. By the movie’s end, though, S.H.I.E.L.D. didn’t just fall apart; it fell off the grid altogether. The Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. show continued the group’s story, but whether that show’s canon anymore is debatable.
Ten years later, not only has S.H.I.E.L.D. been forgotten, but Nick Fury has become a far less prominent character. Not helping matters is the fact that Secret Invasion, the show meant to bring him back into the spotlight, bombed with critics and fans (myself included). In hindsight, that makes the events of the film feel a lot harsher when it comes to Fury. This was the last time he felt as cool as he was supposed to be, really.
The Winter Soldier is Still One of the Best MCU Films
Ten years on, and the MCU is a different landscape from what we had going into The Winter Soldier. Steve Rogers has retired, likely for good, and the Falcon has taken up his mantle as the new Captain America. Fury’s running a new agency in space called S.W.O.R.D.; Nat’s dead. Bucky is working to right the wrongs he committed as HYDRA’s Fist. So, where does this leave The Winter Soldier? Honestly, it still holds up.
Films have come out since then that have topped The Winter Soldier in terms of action, intrigue, and sheer spectacle. But when this first came out ten years ago, it was quickly the best MCU film since the original Avengers movie two years earlier. It raised the stakes and sewed the seeds for the events that would fracture the Avengers in Phase Three. Considering what was coming on the horizon, it did a great job of shaking things up! In short, it’s still awesome and some of Marvel’s best work.
