We’re just mere weeks from one of the most talked about, and perhaps one one of the most anticipated, opening weekends in movie history. December 18th is the date, which will feature two movies that could easily dominate online discussion in their own isolated weekend, but for some reason have chosen to compete with one another. One is Avengers: Doomsday, the other – Denis Villeneuve’s Dune Part Three. While both films can obviously be described as blockbuster fare, what makes the pair an interesting comparison are their differences. Avengers, the most successful franchise in box office history, is as four quadrant as it gets – mixing action with camp and humor, while featuring some of the most recognizable characters in all of fiction. Dune doesn’t have such established iconography on its side. But what it does have appeals to a different type of film fan – one who admires Dune’s alternative filmmaking techniques. The movie was shot on IMAX cameras, and will screen in some theaters on 70mm film stock. There’s a greater emphasis on the quality of cinematography, with Villeneuve embuing his films with heavy contrasts, grand vistas, immaculate close-ups, and a more seamless blend between real sets & soundstages mixed with carefully implemented CGI.
Marvel, by contrast, has never held their cinematography as one of their top priorities, and is more reliant overall on green screens and their optimized post-production process. These aren’t necessarily criticisms of either work, but more of an acknowledgement that both films are in many ways a contrast of styles, each with their camps of fans who prefer each style. Many fans will see both movies, even during opening weekend itself, but I think we all know that Doomsday will handedly win the box office. But will Dune be remembered as the better movie in online discourse? There’s probably countless cinephiles that are eager to tell you it will definitely be the better film, but time with tell. For Marvel, this is but the next chapter to get us ready for whatever the next ten years look like for producer Kevin Feige. For Dune Part Three, there’s much more finality in the air. While it would be a smart bet to say this isn’t the last time we’ll see a movie hitting theaters with ‘Dune’ in the title, it may be the end for Denis Villeneuve’s time with the franchise. The director has stated as much, and also has James Bond on the horizon, but to paraphrase another Bond flick – in Hollywood you can never say never.
But for the moment, fans should approach this 3rd film as if it is definitely the last of its kind for the filmmaker – he’s way too talented and too in demand to need to saddle himself with a 4th entry. With that said, what he and cast & crew have accomplished on the previous two Dune entries have produced some of the best science fiction cinema of the 2020s, and in the process captured the aesthetic and tone of a world many previously thought was unfilmable. Dune Part One was a moody drama full of political intrigue, betrayal, stimulating and bizarre mythology, and dreamlike visuals. Part Two deepened the character relationships while ascending the franchise to new heights in terms of spectacle. The more action heavy of the two previous films, featuring grander setpieces and more impressive physical acts from the characters. Part Three can likely up the ante again, as we’re set to witness the full onslaught of the Galactic Holy War – the prophetic battle that’s already been witnessed by the series’ protagonist – Paul Atreides (Timothy Chalamet).
Paul is a literary icon and partially an inspiration for the creation of Anakin Skywalker – both characters acting as a subversion of the ‘Messiah’ and ‘Hero’s Journey’ tropes. But it will be interesting to see just how polarizing Paul’s full arc will be for movie audiences. (Spoilers) Part Two ends with Paul fulfilling his destiny within the prophecy – assuming the throne of the Imperium by force, and inciting the eventual Holy War. Paul is a complicated character because we’re not really meant to root for him, but he is also not presented as unambiguously evil – at least not at first. Paul’s pursuit of power is initially motivated by revenge; payback to the Harkonnen family for assasinating Paul’s father and ousting the Atreides family. To Paul, this usurping of power is justice in action, it is the righting of a wrong.
However, in the books and what’s telegraphed in the movies, Paul’s use of the Fremen army, which helped him obtain his power, will soon turn deadly, causing apocalyptic destruction across the galaxy. Paul has visions that he can not stop the Fremen once they are unleashed – any action he takes will result in his loss of political power and an increasingly enraged path of destruction by the Fremen, who blindly worship the very prophecy Paul took advantage of to gain power. This posits the Fremen as an unstoppable force, but also paints Paul as a deeply immoral protagonist whose selfish actions have dire consequences. And unlike the aforementioned Anakin Skywalker, who is largely a pawn used by Emperor Palpatine, Paul is generally aware the effects the actions he takes will have, he’s been bred and conditioned to have the power to forsee these effects since his youth.
While Paul’s pursuit of power is not entirely his fault – he is of course a product of the teachings of the Bene Gesserit – his moral failings speak to the messages that Dune author/creator Frank Herbert wished to impart onto his audience. That being the nature and psychology of religious doctrine, aswell as a warning not to blindly trust the infallibility of a leader. For, in Herbert’s opinion, a leader is human and fallible and susceptible to being corrupted by the crooked forces that often congregate around power. In Herbert’s mind, even if that leader proves useful in one situation – we must assign their value as tied to that specific situation, without assuming that the person would be a great leader in all situations, especially as time goes on and circumstances change. That you must always think for yourself and be willing to scrutinize the logic of even great leaders, if such logic is worthy of scrutiny. It is a nuanced view of humanity that is not commonly shared, but it helps to deepen the layers of Dune’s story. If Paul is just a man, a person, someone who is fallible, then his power and his actions much come under scrutiny. Villeneuve is as fitting of a filmmaker we have to tackle these sort of themes, but will the 3rd in the trilogy stick the landing? The film’s final trailer gives us our last glimpse at what is looking to be an epic finale:
This trailer is very good in the ways a lot of final, throw-everything-at-the-wall, spectacle-driven trailers are very good. It’s the immaculate images we know from Villeneuve’s previous two films, but intensified. Most of the characters are not afforded enough screentime here to know how well they’ll be utilized, but there’s enough striking imagery of the likes of Anya Taylor-Joy, Florence Pugh, & Robert Pattinson, among others, to showcase how deep this cast is. But the focus of the trailer’s story is on Paul, and somewhat on Chani (Zendaya). Chani is who is most betrayed by Paul’s actions in Dune Part Two, and it appears here that the strained relationship of these two lovers is going to be even more complicated in the finale.
These events are occurring, as the trailer states, some 19 years after the previous film, and after Paul and the Fremen have ravaged many, many planets. Chani, who staunchly rejected the idea of the prophecy, is at a crossroads when facing the idea that her would-be lover is fulfilling said prophecy. Part 3 is loosely based on Dune Messiah, Herbert’s sequel novel to the original Dune. I say loosely as Villeneuve has hinted the film won’t exactly be a 1-for-1 adaptation of the book, perhaps moreso than the two previous films which already featured some deviations from the novel. But if Messiah is any indication, Paul and Chani’s current predicament and quasi-relationship is going to be extremely messy, to put it mildly. Moreover, Messiah in general is an even darker tale than its predecessor, and (without getting into spoilers) isn’t exactly all sunshine and rainbows for the character of Paul. But will Villeneuve follow the broad events of the novel, or deviate into a new ending for Paul?
I think it’s worth noting that in this latest trailer, there’s hints that the possibility of redemption could be a theme for Paul’s story, or at least something of a sympathetic view of his tragic descent into madness. Or maybe that’s all bait-and-switch, and the film will actually make Paul suffer unambiguously for his actions. The idea of redemption, and if it’s even possible, would be of considerable debate considering the enormity of destruction Paul’s rule leads to. It’s not necessarily a movie’s job to tell people exactly what to think or how to interpret a work, but the film also shouldn’t be too quick to show Paul as worthy of forgiveness or sympathy, approaching the topic with the proper nuance. He’s a man bred for this level of control and destruction since he was a baby, but there’s still plenty to blame within his own actions and obsessive pursuit of power. Villeneuve is one of the best filmmakers working today, so hopefully that nuance is tackled with extreme care, and isn’t drowned out by the awe-inspiring spectacle and violence.
Dune Part Three promises to deliver one of the decade’s most anticipated finales in theaters everywhere on December 18th, 2026.
Discover more from The Game of Nerds
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
