There are three card binders living on my kitchen table right now, and they could not look more different.

Mine is brand new. I opened my first tin of 2026/27 Upper Deck Series One hockey in late October, and I’ve been hooked ever since. I’m chasing as many Young Guns as I can get my hands on, plus anything Penguins or Sharks. Plus any rare parallel that makes my heart skip when it slides out of the pack.

The other two belong to my daughter, Marvel. One is all Pokémon. She’s collecting Delta Reign, the new Mega Rayquaza set that hit shelves November 6, and she’s got a stack of ’90s cards tucked in there too, thanks to her uncles. The other binder is pure Disney Lorcana, and lately she’s been ripping packs from Lorcana’s newest set, Hyperia City.

Same hobby. Different planets.

Or so I thought. The more packs we open around here, the more I wonder which of us is actually on the bigger team. Is Pokémon more popular than sports cards now? Who’s making more money? And why does pulling a Young Guns rookie give me the exact same rush my first grader gets from a sparkly Disney princess?

So I went digging.

The Quick Answer

Pokémon wins the popularity contest, and it isn’t close. Sports cards still move a staggering amount of money, especially at the top end and on the resale market. Lorcana is the newcomer that came in red hot, cooled off a bit, and settled into a loyal community of players and families.

That’s the headline. The details are where it gets fun.

Pokémon Can’t Print Cards Fast Enough

Ten billion cards. That’s roughly how many Pokémon cards were produced worldwide in the fiscal year ending March 31, 2026, according to The Pokémon Company’s own figures, which pushed the lifetime total past 85 billion. Serebii’s Joe Merrick pointed out that almost 12% of every Pokémon card ever made was printed in that single year.

And still, fans are greeted by empty shelves more often than not.

The money matches the hype. The Pokémon Company closed its fiscal year on February 28, 2026 with net sales of 531 billion yen, about $3.3 billion, up 29.3% from the year before. That figure covers video games and mobile too, not just cardboard. But Pokémon Legends: Z-A and the Pokémon TCG Pocket app did much of the heavy lifting, right alongside the physical cards that keep selling out.

Here’s the stat that made me laugh out loud, because it’s basically me with hockey. Circana found that 19% of U.S. adults bought Pokémon cards for themselves within six months, and only about a quarter of those buyers actually play the game.

Grading tells the same story. If you’re new here, grading means mailing a card to a company like PSA, which scores its condition from 1 to 10 and seals it in a plastic slab. In 2025, the major graders handled 16.8 million trading card game and nonsport cards compared to 10 million sports cards, and Pokémon alone accounted for more than 16.1 million of them. Across the big companies, sports card grading actually dropped 12% while TCG grading nearly doubled. In the first half of 2025, 97 of the 100 most graded cards at PSA were Pokémon.

Then there’s the trophy case. In February 2026, Logan Paul’s PSA 10 Pikachu Illustrator sold through Goldin for $16,492,000, which Guinness World Records certified as the most expensive trading card ever sold at auction. That record used to belong to a 1952 Mickey Mantle. Baseball held the crown for years. A yellow electric mouse took it.

One caveat before Pokémon gets too big a head. Modern Pokémon prices took a real hit in 2026, with plenty of recent cards and sealed boxes sliding well below their peaks while top vintage cards kept climbing. Popular and profitable aren’t always the same thing for the person holding the card. Which means the little stack of classic ’90s cards Marvel inherited from her uncles might quietly be the best investment in our house.

Sports Cards Still Bring the Money

So are sports cards losing? Not by a long shot.

Follow the resale dollars and the picture flips. Using eBay’s Collected report figures, VoxBooster tallied about $1.78 billion in sports card singles sold on eBay in 2025, compared to roughly $837 million for trading card game and other nonsport singles combined. The top sellers were neck and neck, though. Charizard pulled in $74 million to Michael Jordan’s $70.5 million.

The manufacturing side is massive too. Fanatics, which bought Topps in 2022, saw its collectibles business bring in roughly $5 billion in 2025, about triple what it did the year before. That number covers more than cards, since it includes memorabilia and live selling, so it isn’t a perfect apples to apples comparison with Pokémon. Still. That’s a lot of rookie cards. And Fanatics keeps stacking leagues, taking over the NFL card license from Panini in April 2026.

Retail data shows the two sides lifting each other up. Circana reported that strategy card games like Pokémon and sports cards from the NFL, MLB, and WNBA together accounted for 70% of the U.S. toy industry’s growth in the first half of 2025. Kidults like me are a big reason why.

Where Hockey Fits In

Hockey is the smaller, scrappier cousin in the sports card family, and I love it for that.

Upper Deck holds the exclusive NHL trading card license, so if you want team logos on your cards, Upper Deck is the only game in town. Series One is the flagship, and the 2026/27 edition hit shelves on October 7 with a 49 player Young Guns rookie class. Young Guns have been the rookie card hockey collectors chase for over three decades, and yes, Celebrini and Matthew Schaefer both show up in the inserts. Hobby boxes are running around $140.

Hockey cards are huge in Canada, and Upper Deck has said it’s still working on growing the hobby in the U.S. The upside for a newbie like me? Series One stays available for months, and the preorder pressure is nowhere near what you see with Pokémon. For someone just starting out, that’s a relief.

Lorcana Came In Like a Firework

Then there’s Marvel’s other binder.

Disney Lorcana launched in 2023 and became the most successful product launch in Ravensburger’s history, helping push the company’s 2024 sales up 18.2% to €790 million. Then reality set in. Ravensburger’s overall sales fell 5.9% in 2025 to €744 million, and the company said Lorcana sales settled at a high level after the initial hype. Buyers who were in it for investment walked away. Players and collectors kept growing.

Honestly? As a mom, I think that’s good news. Fewer flippers means more packs for kids who just want a Coco card.

Lorcana is tiny next to Pokémon, and Ravensburger doesn’t publish Lorcana sales as a standalone number, so there’s no clean dollar comparison. But its first season of competitive Disney Lorcana Challenge events drew more than 17,000 players across nearly 150,000 games. Hyperia City, the 14th set, released October 23 with characters from Pixar’s Coco. Ravensburger is also adding serialized cards limited to 23 copies each through new Collector Boosters.

Numbered chase cards. Sound familiar, sports fans?

Card Collecting Is a Fandom, Plain and Simple

This is the part that really got me.

Swap a few nouns and sports card collectors and Pokémon fans are speaking the same language. We both talk about chase cards and pulls and hits. We both rank our favorites and guard them in sleeves. The two players I hunt hardest are Sidney Crosby and Macklin Celebrini, because one is the face of my Penguins and the other is the future of my Sharks. Marvel wants every Disney princess she can find because she’s a princess girl through and through. That isn’t investing. That’s fandom, the same thing that makes someone buy every variant cover of a comic or track down a first edition of their favorite book.

The events look alike too. Hockey collectors pack into The National in Rosemont each summer, where Upper Deck brought top NHL prospects to meet fans this year. Lorcana fans line up at Disney Springs, where World of Disney ran a virtual queue just to sell Hyperia City on prerelease day. That’s a con crowd, whatever jersey they’re wearing.

Sometimes the crossover is literal. Upper Deck put NHL stars into a DC collection built around Superman this year, and it’s the same company behind Funko’s trading cards. Pokémon is a video game, an anime, and a trading card game all at once, and Lorcana exists entirely because people love Disney. Sports cards exist because people love their teams. It’s the same engine every time: you love something, so you want a little piece of it you can hold.

And the community side? Lorcana’s creative team has talked about meeting people who got married through the game and families who play together. One Austin game store even hosts a Sunday open play just for families whose kids are learning the game. Card shops, live breaks, Discord servers, Facebook groups full of people showing off their pulls. Change the logo and it looks a whole lot like any fandom message board on a Monday morning.

So Who Wins at Our House?

If we’re counting cards printed, cards graded, and grownups buying packs for themselves, Pokémon. Easily. If we’re counting resale dollars and the companies printing the cardboard, sports cards are still a heavyweight. Lorcana is the youngest of the three, smaller and steadier now that the speculators moved on.

But at my kitchen table, nobody’s keeping score. My binder is stacked with Young Guns, Penguins, and Sharks. Marvel’s two hold Delta Reign pulls, ’90s Pokémon from her uncles, and a whole lot of Disney. We both flip the last card in the pack slowly, hoping it’s the good one.

Different fandoms. Same hobby. Same table.


Discover more from The Game of Nerds

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.